Great post Jeff - I like the way you think.
When I left the JWs I was terrified of losing my faith and determined to prove to all the naysayers that I hadn't left Jehovah.
I went to a church and liked what I found there. I became a born again Christian.
After a while though, encouraged in part by good ol' Atheist hubby, Besty, I decided to put my faith to the test like I'd done with the JWs. Christianity, the Bible and God FAILED.
Now I am very happy and content. I strive to the most upright citizen and the best mother, wife, sister and daughter that is humanly possible.
All possible without religion.
I would love to be proved wrong and who knows, one day, maybe I will (but I somehow doubt it)